Seeing Isn't Believing: How Attribution Can Fight the Visual Lie

Third in a series about attribution - by Gary Gardiiner

Today, when appearances often overshadow authenticity, we’ve been conditioned to pursue image over substance. Faux stitching on boots and car seats creates the illusion of craftsmanship without actually providing it, just as filtered Instagram lives are crafted more for engagement than for honesty. Reality, increasingly, is seen as an aesthetic choice rather than a grounded fact.

This isn't just about fashion or filters. It's a cultural pattern.

Faux stitching is a visual trick. It suggests structural integrity where there is none, but no one checks—it just looks right. The same logic powers social media: highly edited selfies suggest health, wealth, or happiness. A mood-lit office hints at productivity. None of it needs to be true. It just needs to pass the eye test.

The problem isn't that visuals are bad. It's that they're unanchored. Without context or verification, we mistake the image for the truth. On social media, this leads to emotional whiplash. People compare themselves to facades. Brands manipulate consumers with fake authenticity. Even in journalism and academia, visuals without attribution can lend a false sense of credibility.

This is where attribution steps in—not just as a citation tool but as a truth signal.

Attribution as a Corrective Lens

Attribution forces a pause. It answers: Where is this from? Who said it? When was it created? Is it edited? Properly attributed content is accountable content. A selfie tagged with who took it, when, and what tools were used (filter, AI, retouching) can't float as easily into the realm of illusion. A stat shared with a link to a reputable source changes how seriously we take it—and whether we share it.

Imagine if every viral tweet included a source link, or if every lifestyle reel revealed sponsorships, editing, or AI generation. Attribution removes the mystery and adds transparency. It makes content traceable, and that's what makes it powerful.

The Visual Will Always Win—But It Doesn't Have to Lie

We won't, and shouldn't, ditch visuals, but we need to bind them more closely to reality. Attribution is how we do that. It's the digital version of real stitching: visible seams that hold the truth together.

Without it, we're all just wearing plastic boots that look hand-stitched.

Part One

Part Two

My Final Photo News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my photography and commentary, become a free or paid subscriber. Subscribe to The Westerville News and PhotoCamp Daily. My Final Photo News also recommends Civic Capacity and Into the Morning by Krista Steele.